Tuesday, January 8, 2008

Katrina claims add up to quadrillions

The most expensive Katrina claims filed so far against the Army Corps of Engineers -- those specifying damages of at least $1 billion each -- total $3 quadrillion, according to a thumbnail set of figures released Monday by the agency.

That's $3,013,283,057,589,910, to be exact. And no cents.

One claim alone accounts for all but $13.3 trillion of the total, and that one came from Baker -- 93 miles northwest of New Orleans and far outside the Katrina flood zone. Federal privacy laws prohibit the corps and plaintiffs' attorneys from identifying claimants by name, so the basis for the Baker claim was not immediately clear.

The corps released a list of 247 claims of $1 billion or more in response to requests from news organizations. Most claims were filed by individuals. Fourteen of them included compensation requests for "wrongful deaths."


The list includes a $77 billion claim filed by the city of New Orleans, which is a matter of public record, as well as three claims by unnamed insurance companies, according to the Bruno & Bruno law firm, which represents thousands of hurricane victims.

Anyone seeking to collect damages from the federal government must first submit a Form 95, which preserves the right to sue. Almost a half-million such forms have been filed with the corps since levees and floodwalls failed during Katrina, triggering catastrophic flooding that killed more than 1,500 people in Louisiana and ruined homes and businesses. Though the accounting is far from finished, it is generally considered the costliest disaster in U.S. history.

The corps reports receiving 489,000 claims as of Monday. But corps spokeswoman Amanda Jones said that a number of those are duplicates.

At the same time, some claims are still being filed, and the corps is adding them to the agency database, Jones said. The filing deadline was Aug. 29, and a lawyer involved in some of the cases said a federal judge will ultimately decide whether to accept claims filed after date.

Lawyer Joe Bruno, who said he represents about 70,000 Katrina victims, is concerned that the dollar value of claims listed on the Form 95s will be used to vilify Katrina victims.

"It will be obscene if anyone uses these to paint our people as being a bunch of money-grubbers," he said. "The forms are a joke, but the government requires them.

None of the claims have been investigated by the corps or presented in court. And until they are verified, Bruno said, it's impossible to know what the real numbers are.

"Government also requires that you put down a figure .¤.¤. although only a judge can determine value." he said. "But here's the deal: Whatever number you put down, you can never get one dollar more than that amount. To be safe and fair, we told folks they'd better put a larger number."

For that reason, Bruno said, the numbers on the claim forms have little to do with what he ultimately expects claimants to recover.

"My best estimate as to the worth of this case .¤.¤. the amount of uncompensated damages .¤.¤. is about $50 billion," he said.

The biggest claim of the 247 is for damages of $3 quadrillion, and it's a personal claim that doesn't include a wrongful death. According to information released by the corps, the claimant listed a ZIP code for Baker, which wasn't directly affected by the levee breaks and subsequent flooding.

Robert Warren II, another lawyer with the Bruno firm, said he doesn't think his firm represents the Baker claimant and that there might be some sort of "issue" with its size.

"It's just speculation on my part without seeing the form," he said. "It could be a data entry error or just emotion. This person could be a relative of someone who was injured or died in the storm."

Or, Warren said, the filer might have mistakenly put a mailing address, perhaps a temporary address used after Katrina, instead of the ZIP code where damages are alleged to have occurred.

In some cases, Bruno said, people put "outrageous" amounts down "because they're outraged.

"Try sitting on your roof for days until you're rescued by a helicopter," he said, "and you'll be outraged, too."

Monday, January 7, 2008

'Pink house' project ends on high note


On Sunday, in front of a backdrop of flamingo-colored houses, hundreds of people celebrated Brad Pitt's Make It Right foundation and caught a rare appearance by the Lower 9th Ward's homegrown superstars: the Lastie family, whose musicians have blown horns and beat drums for this city's finest bands for nearly a century.

"The Lasties are one of the greatest unbroken line of drummers," said writer Jason Berry, who decades ago, made a documentary about two great New Orleans music families: the Nevilles and the Lasties.

The Lastie Family Gospel Choir's afternoon concert marked the end of the art installation of 150 pink fabric homes that appeared in early December as an attention-getter for actor Brad Pitt's nonprofit Make It Right project, which aims to build environmentally friendly, affordable housing for Katrina victims.

To kick off the fundraising, both Pitt and philanthropist Steve Bing, a real-estate developer and film producer, pledged to match up to $5 million in contributions.

The nonprofit is still collecting dollars, but at this point it has raised $10 million matchable dollars from more than 17,000 donors in more than 80 countries.

The donor list is studded with luminaries: Angela Bassett, Bill Cosby, Tom Cruise, Carrie Fisher, Morgan Freeman, Laurence Fishburne, Will Ferrell, Goldie Hawn, Salma Hayek, Ethan Hawke, Angelica Huston, Samuel L. Jackson, Quincy Jones, Lenny Kravitz, Jack Nicholson, Keanu Reeves, Ving Rhames, Tim Robbins and Susan Sarandon, Meg Ryan, Kevin Spacey, David Spade, Oprah Winfrey, Forest Whitaker, Denzel Washington, Barbra Streisand, Russell Simmons, brothers Charlie Sheen and Emilio Estevez, and brothers Branford and Wynton Marsalis.

Tom Darden, the project's executive director, said the exhibit would have had a longer run except for its rented scaffolding, which was needed elsewhere for Carnival.

Once the 40,000 square yards of pink awning material is removed from that scaffolding today and tomorrow, it will be recycled into collectible handbags that will be sold on the Web site for Make It Right, www.makeitrightnola.org.

So far, 70 families have applied for financing from the project, which hopes to break ground in March for the initial 20 of more than 150 houses. The first homes should be finished by the end of summer, Darden said.

By that time, the Lastie family -- independent of Pitt's organization -- also hopes to have a toehold back at the other end of the Lower 9th Ward. Specifically, once Road Home financing materializes, the family wants a new roomy house, built on the corner lot where the big green two-story house once stood, behind centuries-old oak trees.

It's the place that the younger generation of Lastie-family singers ate their way through pounds of red beans and stuffed mirlitons. "We all ate Sunday dinner -- always -- at Teedy Betty's," niece Devora Hampton said, referring to her aunt, Lastie family matriarch Betty Ann Williams.

The older generation knows the demolished house on Delery Street as the rehearsal spot and hangout for musical legends such as Professor Longhair, Oliver "Who Shot the La La" Morgan, pianist Emile Vinette, and Jessie "Ooh Poo Pah Doo" Hill, Williams' uncle.

The family's legacy got its start in the 1930s, when Williams' father, Deacon Frank Lastie Sr., brought drums into Guiding Star Spiritual Church. He was thought to be the first musician in town to incorporate percussion into worship service.

Three of Deacon Lastie's sons also became notable musicians -- trumpeter Melvin Lastie, saxophonist David Lastie and drummer Walter "Popee" Lastie -- as did his two daughters, Williams and her sister Devora Hampton, who lead the choir at St. James Methodist Church, where Williams is organist. A fourth son, Joseph Lastie, raised a drummer son, Joseph "Fish" Lastie, Jr., who Sunday played the drum set behind the family choir, his bass and snare drums matching perfectly with the choir's rhythmic hand-clapping.

Williams' son, top-flight jazz drummer Herlin Riley, was absent Sunday: He was on the road, playing music. When Riley was only 3 months old, his uncle Melvin Lastie began playing his horn by Herlin's crib; when Herlin reached six months, he began trying to blow on a trumpet.

Williams' grandsons, too, pursued music, including the late Joseph Williams, a trombonist, and brother Arian Macklin, a tuba player who now leads the Kinfolk Brass Band. He and his brother both started out on percussion before turning to horn, Macklin said.

"This is a drumming family," he said as his toddler, Joseph Macklin, Deacon Lastie's great-great-grandchild, lay against his chest, tapping a small hand in perfect rhythm.

Williams looked past the stage at the streets she had walked as a young child, before the brick and wood houses had floated away, to be replaced temporarily by pink ones.

"By the hand of God, I know that the 9th Ward will come back," she said. "This is home for me. It's home for our family, for all of us."

Sunday, January 6, 2008

MID-CITY FOILS FOES

Hurricane Katrina damaged its floats in 2005. A tornado tried to wipe out its den in 2007. Yet the Krewe of Mid-City has rolled on each year.

A tornado's destruction couldn't keep it from rolling. Neither could the devastation left in the wake of a catastrophic hurricane.

The Krewe of Mid-City's 18 unique tinfoil floats, including a new float carrying 55 riders, will hit the streets next month, celebrating the organization's 75th anniversary after surviving some major potholes in the road.

With 54 parades on tap, this year's Carnival season officially kicks off today. Mid-City will make its appearance on Feb. 3.


Hurricane Katrina didn't keep Mid-City out of the Carnival 2006 lineup: It paraded with damaged floats gussied up in blue FEMA tarps.

Mid-City's 2007 parade, featuring floats rebuilt in eight weeks by krewe volunteers, went ahead as scheduled despite tornado damage to metal siding on the South Murat Street den a week before the event.

Now -- with the den repaired, all floats redecorated from top to bottom and its first new float since 1974 -- Mid-City seems ready to roll. Except for one problem.

The krewe is having trouble locating all of its living former kings, queens and riders because a database of names and phone numbers was lost when a member's Lakeview home flooded after Katrina, said Gerard Braud, the club's executive officer.

"We've been using Yellow Page searches and Google searches to locate past royalty and riders, but it is not yielding great results," Braud said Thursday, in asking the general public to help find those individuals, many of whom have moved since Katrina. Anyone with such information can send it via e-mail to www.braudcommunications.com or gerard@braudcommunications.com, Braud said.

"We know some of the oldest have passed away but realize their children would like to honor them at the 75th anniversary events," he said.

Katrina causes problems

To some extent, Mid-City's adversity continues because its den has been without electricity since Katrina, except for a brief period just before the club's 2007 parade when the power company installed a temporary meter. The company then removed it after people began using extension cords to steal the building's electricity, Braud said.

But the krewe's decorator, Ricardo Pustanio of Covington, has worked with head lamps and generator-powered lights as he shaped colored aluminum foil, used uniquely by Mid-City, to make the club's 16-rider floats new again and get its first megafloat ready for the streets, Braud said. With repair of its den's metal siding recently finished, Mid-City is waiting for a permit to restore electricity to the building, he said.

Mid-City, formed in 1933 by business owners in that part of town, still bears the name of the neighborhood where it paraded for decades, starting in 1934, with a half dozen floats drawn by mules, a couple of bands and horseback riders. The krewe's first king, Charles A. Bourgeois, who reigned with his wife Gertrude as queen, designed the Mid-City logo, an interlocking heart.


Bourgeois' float designs in 1947 lead to Mid-City being the first krewe to use animation. The movement came courtesy of a group of Boy Scouts, hidden inside the floats, who pedaled stationary bicycles hooked to strings and pulleys that moved the float's decorations.

The Scouts were later replaced by small motors, but the motors have now also gone by the wayside.

"Due to new (city) electrical requirements, we have not reinstated motors on floats since Katrina," said 1989 Mid-City king Michael Haydel, who said meeting the requirements would cost the krewe several thousand dollars.

Despite the absence of pedaling Boy Scouts and motors, Mid City floats will still sparkle. Their sculpted foil decorations are designed to move with the breeze or the rocking from rolling down the street.

With its motto of "Pour La Joie de Vivre," or "For the Joy of Living," Mid-City has gained a reputation for having parade themes dedicated to children and the young at heart.

During a candy-themed parade in 1955, the floats used atomizers to spray the scent of the particular candy represented by the float.

Traditions return

Potato chips made their first appearance as a Carnival throw in 1991, when Mid-City introduced Zapp's chips in 1-ounce packages stamped with the krewe's name.

For two years after Hurricane Katrina, there were no Mid City parade potato chips. But look for them to reappear Feb. 3.

"We redesigned the bag to bring it back for our 75th," Haydel said. "Because of its bright colors, it looks like one of the floats. When the bags fling out of the float, it's going to look like a piece of foil."


Until it left Mid-City in 2002 to parade on St. Charles Avenue, the krewe every year elected a boy and girl from the Ronald McDonald House on Canal Street to serve as honorary king and queen.

Haydel said the krewe is planning to reinstate the practice.

Mid-City, in fact, has a history of reviving its most popular traditions.

One of them, the Greatest Bands in Dixie, was a part of Mid-City parades from the early 1960s until 1983, when the oil bust made it too costly for the krewe to pay the expenses of bands that traveled here from all over the South for the competition, , Haydel said.

But in 2000, the krewe launched what Haydel said is not a battle of bands but a showcase of the greatest bands in America.

This year's parade will feature 10 bands, including the St. Augustine High School band, a "perennial favorite," Haydel said.

The krewe's 2002 move to the St. Charles Avenue parade route came after the New Orleans Police Department, dealing with post-Sept. 11 security concerns, said it couldn't provide security for both an Uptown and a Mid City route.

Braud, who in 2001 was the last king to preside over the krewe's original route, said that even before Mid-City began using the St. Charles Avenue route six years ago, the number of spectators lined up for its parade on Canal Street had begun to drop considerably in the blocks below Jefferson Davis Parkway.

One year, he said, "there were more cops in some blocks than people. It was truly embarrassing"

After a slight dip in membership the year after Katrina, Mid-City's roster is back up to 250, including 55 women. About a third of the members live outside Louisiana. Of the rest, only two people, a couple who joined last summer, actually live in Mid-City.

Friday, January 4, 2008

GAO noted that the Corps' rush to award contract

The Army Corps of Engineers followed federal rules when it awarded a contract to a politically connected manufacturer to provide pumps to this city after Hurricane Katrina, Congress' investigative arm said Thursday.

The Government Accountability Office reaffirmed findings it made in May after the Office of Special Counsel, an independent federal whistleblower agency, said in October that there was a ''substantial likelihood'' the Corps acted improperly in handling the contract.

The report was the latest look at the contract awarded in early 2006 to Moving Water Industries Corp. Corps officials in New Orleans installed the company's 34 pumps before the 2006 hurricane season despite allegations by Maria Garzino, the engineer who oversaw their installation, that the pumps would fail during a hurricane.

''The Corps' actions in awarding and administering the pumping system contract were generally in accordance with federal requirements,'' the new report said.

The GAO, however, noted that the Corps' rush to award the contract ''resulted in deficiencies in key contract provisions.''

The report said the agency performed ''limited market research,'' used specifications for the pumps very similar to MWI's and drafted a contract ''not written as precisely as it should have been.''

The pumps were plagued by numerous problems, including undersized gear oil circulation motors, vibrations and suspect pipe welds, resulting in a lower pumping capacity than expected, the GAO said.

In the future, the GAO said, the Corps should do a better job, even during emergencies, of following ''sound acquisition practices'' and making sure that a contract's criteria, such as testing requirements, are spelled out clearly.

The GAO also noted that although the pumps were deficient during the 2006 hurricane season, as of September 2007 the Corps said it had corrected flaws with the equipment and successfully tested the pumps for two hours each.

The Corps has added a new series of pumps on the canals built by different manufacturers to bolster pumping capacity. Corps officials declined to comment on the report.

William E. Bucknam, MWI's vice president and general counsel, said the report ''confirms the position we have taken all along that MWI did in fact deliver on this critical pump contract under extremely challenging circumstances and strict time constraints.''

MWI is owned by J. David Eller and his sons. Eller was once a business partner of former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush in a venture called Bush-El that marketed MWI pumps.

In the coming weeks, the Corps is expected to decide whether MWI should be awarded a $5 million bonus for delivering the pumps before June 1, 2006, or pay a penalty for late delivery of $1,700 per pump a day, the GAO said

Thursday, January 3, 2008

Highway barriers being used to protect EJ levees, GREAT JOB!


Huge concrete traffic barriers have been pressed into service along the Lake Pontchartrain shoreline to help retard erosion in East Jefferson, where research shows more than 175 acres have been lost in the past 50 years.

Land loss is so severe in some spots, especially in Kenner, that the waterline is within 20 to 30 feet of hurricane protection levee toes and floodwalls, said Executive Director Fran Campbell of the East Jefferson Levee District.


Hundreds of the 3-ton highway barriers, each about 15 feet long and almost three tall, were put in place recently to slow land loss and to stabilize a new breakwater that will be built with some $10 million worth of rock, Campbell said. The rock will replace the breakwater that Hurricane Katrina destroyed on Aug. 29, 2005, just after the Levee District finished building it.

"I can't tell you how much protection we believe that rock provided our levees during the storm, and it's critical that we get it replaced," she said.

FEMA has agreed to pay for the rock.

Campbell anticipates that the Southeast Louisiana Flood Protection Authority-East, now starting its second year managing two levee districts east of the Mississippi River, will advertise early this year for an engineer to design the new breakwater.

In the meantime, Campbell has secured more than 1,000 traffic barriers from the state Department of Transportation and Development for erosion control structures along two sections of the lakefront.

The old "Jersey barriers," so named because they originated in New Jersey, are being replaced on road jobs with newer versions, said Mike Stack, state highway department chief in New Orleans.

"These barriers don't meet the new standards, so we're phasing them out for traffic control on all our highway projects," Stack said. "We can still use them to block ramps and such, but we have enough for that. Using them (on the lakefront) seems to be a good thing to do."

Over the past several months, the barriers have been lined up along the two sections of the East Jefferson shoreline. In Kenner, the barriers stretch along Reach 1 between the St. Charles Parish line and Duncan Canal, where Levee District research shows a land loss of more than 630 acres just west of Williams Boulevard.

Barriers also were placed between Causeway Boulevard and the New Orleans line, where Campbell said they can help protect land restoration work done by Levee District personnel in the past several months.

The breakwater that Katrina's storm surge washed away was built using mostly broken concrete generated when an old airport runway was removed and rebuilt. Louis Armstrong New Orleans International Airport donated the riprap to the Levee District.

The new breakwater will be built with more than 100,000 tons of rock, and FEMA guidelines require that the material be limited to replacing rock lost to Katrina. That means most of it will be used along levee Reach 4, between Causeway Boulevard and the Suburban Canal, and Reach 1 in Kenner.

The remaining 8,000 tons of FEMA rock will be distributed along the other three reaches of East Jefferson levee.

Campbell said the Levee District is coordinating its efforts with the Army Corps of Engineers to ensure that rock construction doesn't interfere with efforts to raise the lakefront levees.

She also hopes that a robust breakwater along the entire 11-mile East Jefferson lakefront ultimately will be incorporated into a major wetlands building and land reclamation project.

"We're doing what we have to now to get some additional protection and address erosion, but whatever we do out there will be something that we can build on," Campbell said. "And we hope everyone will be sitting around the same table to make sure that happens."